Ups & Downs (Edogawa Q&A)

[Kitsuki Edogawa]

I'm still figuring things out, but I had fun.

[Fukurokujin]

Thanks for joining us!

Planning on bringing Edogawa back?

If not, what do you see him doing next?

[Saibankan]

What did you like most about the game narratively? What did you like least about the game narratively?

What did you like most about the game mechanically? What did you like least about the game mechanically?

What would you really like to see in the next game that wasn't in this game?


I really liked the conclusion of your thread with Isawa Mari. I know you don't often have time to do longer form posts, but when you do, they really shine.

[Kitsuki Edogawa]

Thanks for joining us!

Planning on bringing Edogawa back?

If not, what do you see him doing next?

More than likely, I'll reprise Edogawa., given the opportunity. He's still seeking a magistrate appointment, so that's his focus going forward.

What did you like most about the game narratively? What did you like least about the game narratively?

What did you like most about the game mechanically? What did you like least about the game mechanically?

What would you really like to see in the next game that wasn't in this game?


I really liked the conclusion of your thread with Isawa Mari. I know you don't often have time to do longer form posts, but when you do, they really shine.

I was more comfortable with the system this time around, which removed much of the stress I was feeling last time. I really enjoyed the overall format of the game. I felt it worked well. But, I do like having things to explore.

Mechanically, I feel like I still have a lot to learn. Edogawa's sheet feels a bit random but, I am beginning to figure things out. Kitsuki's Method may be the hardest thing for me to figure out. I appreciate the flavor of it, but ot feels limiting.

[Usagi Kaigen]

Beware the DREADED FORM QUESTIONS!

1. Biggest curveball Edogawa threw you?
2. Biggest curveball the game threw you?
3. Biggest Missed Opportunity?

[Isawa Mari]

Thanks for the thread with Hana's challenge puzzle in it...particularly as I plodded through with my vacation schedule (mom's quite jealous of my time when I'm visiting--understandably). I was curious what threads someone might follow to find that sort of answer and appreciated the chance to flesh out some details of her ribbons a bit more.

[Hida Masayuki]

I'll second that. I enjoyed the threads you were in and that one in particular was well written. Hope to see you next time.

[Kitsuki Edogawa]

Beware the DREADED FORM QUESTIONS!

1. Biggest curveball Edogawa threw you?
2. Biggest curveball the game threw you?
3. Biggest Missed Opportunity?

1: I'm still not quite in his headspace. That happens with characters sometimes, but this is his second game. I felt a bit more comfortable, but I haven't gotten him figured out yet.

2: I struggled a lot with the system at Shika. I'm still learning, but I had a much easier time with this game.

3: I always regret the threads I didn't have. I also should have spent my xp.