GM Questions
- Isawa Mari
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Sun Jun 09, 2024 6:54 am
Re: GM Questions
Using Invocations in Confront the Danger: Is no benefit to bonus successes intentional? Asking since it's so consistent elsewhere where more power would seem to offer more result. (vs. waking up which is pretty much yes/no)
Phoenix * Medic * Short * Plump * Beribboned * 5th Kaisha
Honor: 62 * Glory: 49 * Status 30
Description
"Sand or stones in your footwear when you wake? Inauspicious. You’re warned to tread carefully."
Honor: 62 * Glory: 49 * Status 30
Description
"Sand or stones in your footwear when you wake? Inauspicious. You’re warned to tread carefully."
-
- Posts: 23
- Joined: Sun Jun 02, 2024 6:28 am
Re: GM Questions
Complementary to Mari's question above, Re: D6 event, the Confronting Danger roll:
It appears that if a shugenja casts an invocation instead of just using Theology for an "attack," they're trading a TN 3 with "bonus success can score extra momentum" for whatever the invocations TN is and a flat score of momentum = invocation rank.
Am I reading that correctly?
It appears that if a shugenja casts an invocation instead of just using Theology for an "attack," they're trading a TN 3 with "bonus success can score extra momentum" for whatever the invocations TN is and a flat score of momentum = invocation rank.
Am I reading that correctly?
Scorpion Clan * Shugenja * Scholar * Notices things * Seems anxious
Honor 50 | Status 40 | Glory 45
Wears: respectable kimono, wakizashi, scroll satchel with pocket of shuriken. Concealed armor, bo and loyal pony with medicine kit on the march.
Honor 50 | Status 40 | Glory 45
Wears: respectable kimono, wakizashi, scroll satchel with pocket of shuriken. Concealed armor, bo and loyal pony with medicine kit on the march.
- Fukurokujin
- Posts: 308
- Joined: Wed Oct 18, 2023 7:44 pm
Re: GM Questions
I'm going to say no at this point.Utaku Mukai wrote: ↑Wed Jun 26, 2024 2:28 amI assume, since it's not listed, that we don't get stance bonuses in the Confront the Danger step?
Fukurokujin
Unaligned GM * Experienced More Than Is Good for Him
"Is that wise?"
Unaligned GM * Experienced More Than Is Good for Him
"Is that wise?"
- Fukurokujin
- Posts: 308
- Joined: Wed Oct 18, 2023 7:44 pm
Re: GM Questions
Isawa Mari wrote: ↑Wed Jun 26, 2024 4:44 amUsing Invocations in Confront the Danger: Is no benefit to bonus successes intentional? Asking since it's so consistent elsewhere where more power would seem to offer more result. (vs. waking up which is pretty much yes/no)
The part about invocations has been adjusted. Benefit to bonus successes added.Yogo Osamu wrote: ↑Wed Jun 26, 2024 5:28 amComplementary to Mari's question above, Re: D6 event, the Confronting Danger roll:
It appears that if a shugenja casts an invocation instead of just using Theology for an "attack," they're trading a TN 3 with "bonus success can score extra momentum" for whatever the invocations TN is and a flat score of momentum = invocation rank.
Am I reading that correctly?
Fukurokujin
Unaligned GM * Experienced More Than Is Good for Him
"Is that wise?"
Unaligned GM * Experienced More Than Is Good for Him
"Is that wise?"
- Usagi Kaigen
- Posts: 236
- Joined: Fri May 31, 2024 9:43 am
Re: GM Questions
Another event question...
Relevant to scoring.
Does the baseline first attempt on waking up count against your momentum? (i.e. a Vigilance 2 character cannot contribute more than 1 momentum at that stage) As written it would seem so.
Relevant to scoring.
Does the baseline first attempt on waking up count against your momentum? (i.e. a Vigilance 2 character cannot contribute more than 1 momentum at that stage) As written it would seem so.
Usagi Kaigen
Hare Clan • Bushi • Soldier • Resigned • Hick • Second Kaisha
Honor: 49 Status: 25 Glory: 44
Carries: Daisho, knives, clothing, and a finger of jade. Has ashigaru armor for dicier situations.
"I must have misunderstood."
Hare Clan • Bushi • Soldier • Resigned • Hick • Second Kaisha
Honor: 49 Status: 25 Glory: 44
Carries: Daisho, knives, clothing, and a finger of jade. Has ashigaru armor for dicier situations.
"I must have misunderstood."
- Agasha Daikumo
- Posts: 107
- Joined: Mon Jun 10, 2024 2:03 am
Re: GM Questions
so... im on confront the danger, and that says it triggers ferocity, but ferocity only says it applies when you are trying to hold back or be precise... so does it not trigger for me because I support putting down a madman attacking his allies immediately? because daikumo would be striking to kill (though i understand nobody will be getting the kill other than an NPC because event and story)
Just saying, he's ferocious and wouldn't hold back, so would he get strife if he's not actually trying to hold back?
i'll take the strife if it's mechanically expected, just don't know if it applies since I have no intention of holding back and will be supporting the execution option after
Just saying, he's ferocious and wouldn't hold back, so would he get strife if he's not actually trying to hold back?
i'll take the strife if it's mechanically expected, just don't know if it applies since I have no intention of holding back and will be supporting the execution option after
Dragon Clan • Samurai • 4th Kaisha • Shugenja • Large Stature • Chooses Brusqueness
Status 41 • Glory 42 • Honor 46
Status 41 • Glory 42 • Honor 46
Re: GM Questions
Fair points. It's a bit odd for both soft-hearted and ferocity to both trigger here. I'll remove ferocity for this step. Still stays on the Jizo step, as you either have to check yourself to argue to spare him, or not scream KILL at the top of your lungs.Agasha Daikumo wrote: ↑Thu Jun 27, 2024 12:32 amso... im on confront the danger, and that says it triggers ferocity, but ferocity only says it applies when you are trying to hold back or be precise... so does it not trigger for me because I support putting down a madman attacking his allies immediately? because daikumo would be striking to kill (though i understand nobody will be getting the kill other than an NPC because event and story)
Just saying, he's ferocious and wouldn't hold back, so would he get strife if he's not actually trying to hold back?
i'll take the strife if it's mechanically expected, just don't know if it applies since I have no intention of holding back and will be supporting the execution option after
Non-Human || GM || Headmaster of Hope's Peak Academy
"Now then, what is it you want to show us? It better not be boring, or I'll be VERY unhappy~!"
"Now then, what is it you want to show us? It better not be boring, or I'll be VERY unhappy~!"
- Fukurokujin
- Posts: 308
- Joined: Wed Oct 18, 2023 7:44 pm
Re: GM Questions
If I understand your question correctly, yes.Usagi Kaigen wrote: ↑Wed Jun 26, 2024 10:25 pmDoes the baseline first attempt on waking up count against your momentum? (i.e. a Vigilance 2 character cannot contribute more than 1 momentum at that stage) As written it would seem so.
Fukurokujin
Unaligned GM * Experienced More Than Is Good for Him
"Is that wise?"
Unaligned GM * Experienced More Than Is Good for Him
"Is that wise?"
- Doji Hametsu
- Posts: 218
- Joined: Sat Jun 01, 2024 8:07 pm
Re: GM Questions
Now, when you say Bonus Successes deriving from the Kuni portion of the D6 event can be applied to future rolls, does that mean I get to treat them like they inflate my success after I have already succeeded at a roll, or can I use them to help meet a TN?
* Crane Clan * Fourth Kaisha * Courtier * Adjutant * Fastidious * Ambitious * Famously Reliable * Whispers of Cruelty *
Honor: 63. Glory: 58, Status: 40
Equipped: Lacquered armor, Yari, Yumi
Honor: 63. Glory: 58, Status: 40
Equipped: Lacquered armor, Yari, Yumi
- Fukurokujin
- Posts: 308
- Joined: Wed Oct 18, 2023 7:44 pm
Re: GM Questions
You may use them to help meet a TN.Doji Hametsu wrote: ↑Fri Jun 28, 2024 12:36 pmNow, when you say Bonus Successes deriving from the Kuni portion of the D6 event can be applied to future rolls, does that mean I get to treat them like they inflate my success after I have already succeeded at a roll, or can I use them to help meet a TN?
I'll update the event post.
Fukurokujin
Unaligned GM * Experienced More Than Is Good for Him
"Is that wise?"
Unaligned GM * Experienced More Than Is Good for Him
"Is that wise?"
- Daidoji Nobu
- Posts: 112
- Joined: Sat Jun 01, 2024 6:33 am
Re: GM Questions
Are people who participated in the day 6 EN event unable to get 3 consecutive timeslots of sleep for day 7? Or do multiple days pass off-screen between day 6 and day 7?For the new day, if you got three consecutive timeslots of sleep, you start with 0 Strife and Void Points equal to your Void; you also recover Endurance equal to your Water x 2 if you need it.
Crane Clan • Samurai • Fourth Kaisha • Large Stature • Whispers of Failure
Status 40 • Glory 52 • Honor 64
Status 40 • Glory 52 • Honor 64
- Kasuga Yoshi
- Posts: 167
- Joined: Sat Jun 01, 2024 9:17 pm
Re: GM Questions
Looking at the Kuni opposed roll and it looks like 4e?
Also, now that we are here I assume Coursing March chant is no longer viable. Would Fortress of Necessity be useful to erect or maintain some temporary fortifications?Make a contested roll of your Element / Courtesy against the Kuni’s 5k2 (roll for both, please
Tortoise Clan | Honor: It's about appearances | Glory: Disappointment| Status: Normal of a Great Clan Samurai
Male | "Logistician" | Groomed | Generous | Strife with Mantis
Equipment (standard): Traveling clothes, wakizashi, calligraphy set, knife, kiseru, abacus or gaijin compass, travelling pack, pouch of gaijin coins
(Battle): Tetsubo
4th Kaisha!
"It's an absolute pleasure to see you again. Here, please take this gift. I insist"
Theme Song: Smooth Criminal (Shamisen Style!)
Male | "Logistician" | Groomed | Generous | Strife with Mantis
Equipment (standard): Traveling clothes, wakizashi, calligraphy set, knife, kiseru, abacus or gaijin compass, travelling pack, pouch of gaijin coins
(Battle): Tetsubo
4th Kaisha!
"It's an absolute pleasure to see you again. Here, please take this gift. I insist"
Theme Song: Smooth Criminal (Shamisen Style!)
- Doji Hametsu
- Posts: 218
- Joined: Sat Jun 01, 2024 8:07 pm
Re: GM Questions
I interpreted that as 3 skill dice and 2 ring dice. It's just in 4e notation, but you still keep dice equal to the ring. I think it must not matter which ring they're using.
* Crane Clan * Fourth Kaisha * Courtier * Adjutant * Fastidious * Ambitious * Famously Reliable * Whispers of Cruelty *
Honor: 63. Glory: 58, Status: 40
Equipped: Lacquered armor, Yari, Yumi
Honor: 63. Glory: 58, Status: 40
Equipped: Lacquered armor, Yari, Yumi
- Fukurokujin
- Posts: 308
- Joined: Wed Oct 18, 2023 7:44 pm
Re: GM Questions
We're hand-waving a lot of transit time. You are considered to have had your timeslots of sleep.Daidoji Nobu wrote: ↑Fri Jun 28, 2024 1:07 pmAre people who participated in the day 6 EN event unable to get 3 consecutive timeslots of sleep for day 7? Or do multiple days pass off-screen between day 6 and day 7?For the new day, if you got three consecutive timeslots of sleep, you start with 0 Strife and Void Points equal to your Void; you also recover Endurance equal to your Water x 2 if you need it.
It is Skill + Ring, 3 Skill and 2 Ring.Kasuga Yoshi wrote: ↑Fri Jun 28, 2024 1:18 pmLooking at the Kuni opposed roll and it looks like 4e?
Also, now that we are here I assume Coursing March chant is no longer viable. Would Fortress of Necessity be useful to erect or maintain some temporary fortifications?Make a contested roll of your Element / Courtesy against the Kuni’s 5k2 (roll for both, please
Coursing March would not be viable, no. Fortress of Necessity would only provoke laughter from the Kaiu; you are at The Wall, after all.
Fukurokujin
Unaligned GM * Experienced More Than Is Good for Him
"Is that wise?"
Unaligned GM * Experienced More Than Is Good for Him
"Is that wise?"
- Kasuga Yoshi
- Posts: 167
- Joined: Sat Jun 01, 2024 9:17 pm
Re: GM Questions
For the 1st stage of the event is the Kuni success the TN to hit or does it need to be exceeded?
Tortoise Clan | Honor: It's about appearances | Glory: Disappointment| Status: Normal of a Great Clan Samurai
Male | "Logistician" | Groomed | Generous | Strife with Mantis
Equipment (standard): Traveling clothes, wakizashi, calligraphy set, knife, kiseru, abacus or gaijin compass, travelling pack, pouch of gaijin coins
(Battle): Tetsubo
4th Kaisha!
"It's an absolute pleasure to see you again. Here, please take this gift. I insist"
Theme Song: Smooth Criminal (Shamisen Style!)
Male | "Logistician" | Groomed | Generous | Strife with Mantis
Equipment (standard): Traveling clothes, wakizashi, calligraphy set, knife, kiseru, abacus or gaijin compass, travelling pack, pouch of gaijin coins
(Battle): Tetsubo
4th Kaisha!
"It's an absolute pleasure to see you again. Here, please take this gift. I insist"
Theme Song: Smooth Criminal (Shamisen Style!)
- Fukurokujin
- Posts: 308
- Joined: Wed Oct 18, 2023 7:44 pm
Re: GM Questions
Meet the TN to pass.Kasuga Yoshi wrote: ↑Fri Jun 28, 2024 2:25 pmFor the 1st stage of the event is the Kuni success the TN to hit or does it need to be exceeded?
Fukurokujin
Unaligned GM * Experienced More Than Is Good for Him
"Is that wise?"
Unaligned GM * Experienced More Than Is Good for Him
"Is that wise?"
- Daidoji Nobu
- Posts: 112
- Joined: Sat Jun 01, 2024 6:33 am
Re: GM Questions
This Event consists of three parts, which must be attempted in order; each PC may make a TOTAL number of rolls in the Event equal to their Focus + 1. Any part of the Event not attempted is considered to be failed, with the listed consequences.
If I make multiple rolls for the "Get Settled" step, do I count Success/Failure for each roll, or only the best roll?Get Settled
After being briefed, there is some small time to integrate with the Crab forces who do this every day. Roll Games, Performance, or Labor, any approach, TN 3, to make some demonstration that pleases lookers-on. Success adds your Vigilance to the Legion’s Discipline, plus 1 for every 2 bonus successes; failure reduces the Legion’s Discipline by an amount equal to your Glory Rank, as your lack of knowledge influences those who look up to you.
Example: I try three rolls. My first roll fails (Discipline -6). My second roll succeeds with 2 bonus successes (Discipline +4). My third roll succeeds with 3 bonus successes (Discipline +4). Do I apply all three effects (net effect Discipline +2), or only the best one (Discipline +4)?
A related question: if I use opportunities to reduce strife or gain tidbits of information, can I use the opportunities from all three rolls, or only the best one?
Crane Clan • Samurai • Fourth Kaisha • Large Stature • Whispers of Failure
Status 40 • Glory 52 • Honor 64
Status 40 • Glory 52 • Honor 64
Re: GM Questions
Each roll, all oppsDaidoji Nobu wrote: ↑Fri Jun 28, 2024 6:25 pmThis Event consists of three parts, which must be attempted in order; each PC may make a TOTAL number of rolls in the Event equal to their Focus + 1. Any part of the Event not attempted is considered to be failed, with the listed consequences.If I make multiple rolls for the "Get Settled" step, do I count Success/Failure for each roll, or only the best roll?Get Settled
After being briefed, there is some small time to integrate with the Crab forces who do this every day. Roll Games, Performance, or Labor, any approach, TN 3, to make some demonstration that pleases lookers-on. Success adds your Vigilance to the Legion’s Discipline, plus 1 for every 2 bonus successes; failure reduces the Legion’s Discipline by an amount equal to your Glory Rank, as your lack of knowledge influences those who look up to you.
Example: I try three rolls. My first roll fails (Discipline -6). My second roll succeeds with 2 bonus successes (Discipline +4). My third roll succeeds with 3 bonus successes (Discipline +4). Do I apply all three effects (net effect Discipline +2), or only the best one (Discipline +4)?
A related question: if I use opportunities to reduce strife or gain tidbits of information, can I use the opportunities from all three rolls, or only the best one?
Non-Human || GM || Headmaster of Hope's Peak Academy
"Now then, what is it you want to show us? It better not be boring, or I'll be VERY unhappy~!"
"Now then, what is it you want to show us? It better not be boring, or I'll be VERY unhappy~!"
- Agasha Daikumo
- Posts: 107
- Joined: Mon Jun 10, 2024 2:03 am
Re: GM Questions
So, the benefit from great luck at the festival seems like it's equivalent to a Distinction for one roll. I believe distinctions and adversities cancel each other out if you have 1 of each that applies to a roll? Can I use that one time bonus to cancel a triggered adversity on an event roll? Or do I have that all wrong?
Dragon Clan • Samurai • 4th Kaisha • Shugenja • Large Stature • Chooses Brusqueness
Status 41 • Glory 42 • Honor 46
Status 41 • Glory 42 • Honor 46
Re: GM Questions
All seems to be in order, sureAgasha Daikumo wrote: ↑Fri Jun 28, 2024 6:37 pmSo, the benefit from great luck at the festival seems like it's equivalent to a Distinction for one roll. I believe distinctions and adversities cancel each other out if you have 1 of each that applies to a roll? Can I use that one time bonus to cancel a triggered adversity on an event roll? Or do I have that all wrong?
Non-Human || GM || Headmaster of Hope's Peak Academy
"Now then, what is it you want to show us? It better not be boring, or I'll be VERY unhappy~!"
"Now then, what is it you want to show us? It better not be boring, or I'll be VERY unhappy~!"